I’M STILL HERE (2024, Brazil)

January 11, 2025

Greetings again from the darkness. True stories are often at the heart of many movies each year. However, there are true stories and then there is the story of the Paiva family. Marcelo Rubens Paiva has written two books, which along with numerous interviews with family and friends, serve as the basis for this film from famed Brazilian director Walter Salles (THE MOTORCYCLE DIARIES.2004). The screenplay comes from co-writers Murilo Hauser and Heitor Lorega.

Unless you are a history scholar, it’s highly unlikely you can recite the various Latin America dictatorships and military coups over the past decades. Yet you surely know they have happened, and that many innocent people and families have been victimized. The Paiva family is one example, and their story is gut-wrenching. The film begins in Rio de Janeiro in 1970 when military rule was in place. Director Salles affords us plenty of time to get to know architect Rubens Paiva (Selton Mello), his wife Eunice (Fernanda Torres), and their five kids. Theirs is a happy family living a pleasant and comfortable life … gatherings on the beach, music and dancing, family meals and photos. In one moment, the happiness fades and things change forever.

A group of men show up to escort Rubens (a long-ago local Congressman) in for a deposition. He smiles and tells the family that he will be back soon. The saga of this family is torturous to watch. Eunice and her oldest daughter are soon taken in and held for questioning in what appears to be some type of prison or military facility. They learn Rubens is accused of being a communist. Eunice’s return home is a beautifully filmed sequence, as it’s nighttime and the kids are sleeping.

The next morning’s reunion is touching, yet now the reality has hit for the older daughters. Eunice kicks into strong woman mode to protect her “babies”. The story shifts significantly here since the wage earner is gone. Eunice sells the house and the family moves to Sao Paulo. Eunice handles the extreme stress, continues caring for her kids, and never stops trying to find out about Rubens.

The journey of Eunice could easily fill a movie, however, Salles chooses to jump ahead 25 years (to 1996) and then again to 2014, when the family is together and wheelchair bound and Alzheimer’s stricken Eunice is played by 95-year-old Fernanda Montenegro (Oscar nominated for CENTRAL STATION, 1998), the real-life mother of Fernanda Torres. During these segments, we figure out what an impressive woman Eunice is and how much she has accomplished through determination. It’s likely a death certificate has never been more valued or more pursued than the one Eunice finally receives. We also see her son Marcelo is now physically disabled, yet becoming famous as a writer.  

Director Walter Salles knew the Paiva family quite well when he was young, and his personal connection shines through in this ode to a family shattered by political turmoil. Fernanda Torres delivers a stunning performance with more emotional depth than just about any other acting performance we’ve seen this year. Salles details that more than 20,000 citizens were tortured and held captive over these years, and via the closing credits he runs archival photos and a recap of history. Seeing the stress and turmoil of a previously happy family is not an easy watch, yet perhaps the accomplishments of Eunice help offset some of the pain.

WATCH THE TRAILER

Leave a Comment » | Drama, World Cinema/Foreign | Tagged: , , , , , , , | Permalink
Posted by David Ferguson

WILL & HARPER (2024)

January 11, 2025

Greetings again from the darkness. Realistically speaking, there should be more words for ‘friendship’, designating the multiple levels on which ‘being friends’ can occur. If Financial Advisors can have “A” (like Warren Buffett), B, C, and D (like me) clients, then wouldn’t it be reasonable for us to have levels of friendship for those we entrust with our kids and a house key versus those we meet periodically for happy hour, or those we acknowledge in the grocery store with a wave and a smile? OK, so while the viability of friendship by ranking is not likely, this latest from Josh Greenbaum (BARB AND STAR GO TO VISTA DEL MAR, 2021) introduces us to a friendship we can all strive for.

Andrew Steele was the head writer for “Saturday Night Live” from 1995 through 2008. Nominated many times for Emmys and WGA awards, he won an Emmy in 2002. During the time at SNL, Steele struck up a friendship with the great Will Ferrell, who was a memorable cast member from 1995 through 2002, before striking gold in movies. Almost thirty years into the friendship, Steele informed Ferrell that Andrew was now Harper (an interesting story behind the name choice), and her transition had begun in 2022. Now, keep in mind that Will Ferrell is a guy in his mid-50’s. Sure, he’s been around Hollywood for decades … but still, this information from a long-time friend would surprise most anyone.

Going back to levels of friendship, Ferrell suggests the two take one of Harper’s beloved cross-country road trips together. Watching the film, it plays like Ferrell prefaces this as a way for the two to reconnect, but on a deeper level, it translates into Ferrell making it easier for Harper to get more comfortable in public with her new self. Either way, this is a friendship to admire and the type of character we should each respect.

We have all seen many movies where buddies take a road trip together. However, these 16 days become much more personal and eye-opening than the average buddy flick. The two friends exchange personal details, and respectfully, Ferrell allows Harper to vocalize and process what this new identity means, how it feels, and how she is accepted by others (who are not long-time friends). There are many stops along the way, including parking lots, sporting events, and a dive bar in Oklahoma. Most of this provides some insight, although the over-staged bits (disguises) seem out of place.

Will Ferrell does in fact reward us with doses of humor. “Are you a worse driver now?” is an instant classic, and their friendship-based banter helps us feel like we are along for the ride. There are segments featuring Harper’s daughters and SNL celebrities, and Harper sometimes reminds us of her prolific comedic writing skills. Perhaps the most telling interactions are those with strangers – related both to Ferrell’s status and Harper’s gender. These days, there is a growing anti-trans sentiment that threatens to destroy the advances made over the past years. It seems to me that the message being delivered here is not one of celebration or special treatment, but rather acceptance and friendship … allowing adults to be who and what they want to be, as long as they aren’t harming others. That also seems like the definition of human decency. This one will likely have you analyzing your own reactions, and you’ll definitely want to stick around for Kristin Wiig’s remarkable song at the end.

available on Netflix

WATCH THE TRAILER

Leave a Comment » | Documentary | Tagged: , , | Permalink
Posted by David Ferguson

THE SEED OF THE SACRED FIG (2024, Germany)

January 10, 2025

Greetings again from the darkness. In the year of long movies, this is one of the longer ones at two hours and forty-eight minutes. Also, in the year of only a few great movies, this is one of them. Writer-director Mohammad Rasoulof was arrested and sentenced for criticizing the Iranian government. He subsequently escaped and fled the country, only to show up for his film’s premiere at the Cannes Film Festival. This is Germany’s submission for the best Foreign Language Oscar.

On the surface, this seems like a simple story. Amidst severe and sometimes violent political unrest in Tehran, a man’s gun goes missing, which could cost him his job. He proceeds to accuse his wife and daughters of taking the gun, and takes such extreme measures in solving the theft that he destroys the fabric of the family. In the United States, we have recently witnessed how political discord can negatively impact family bonds, yet this pales in comparison to what occurs in countries like Iran. The violence in the street too often results in bloodshed that finds its way into homes.

Iman (Missagh Zareh) has not yet had time to celebrate his job promotion in the prosecutor’s office when he’s expected to file a false report regarding a case investigation. The result of the report would likely lead to the prisoner’s execution. It’s just ‘playing ball’ … or office politics (unless of course you are the one to be executed). The increased perks with his new position also bump up the level of danger for Iman and his family. As often happens with the younger generation, his daughters Rezvan (Mahsa Rostami) and Sana (Setareh Maleki) support the rebellion, which puts their mother Najmeh (Soheila Golestani) in the unenviable position of disagreeing with her daughters, yet having to protect them from their establishment father.

Director Rasoulof expertly weaves storylines of politics, family dynamics, societal upheaval, and generational differences into an incredibly interesting and often tense film without sugarcoating with unnecessary cliches or easy answers. This is what real life can look like – decisions have ramifications. Fingernail polish and protests can be related, and once again we see that it’s not paranoia if they are after you.

The film opens with an explanation of the sacred fig, and as the story unfolds, we catch the tie-in. We know that times change, and each generation brings new ideas and preferences. We also know that these transitions can range from clunky to violent. There is an extremely effective chase scene through the ruins of a deserted town, and it plays directly to the point that these family members are on different tracks. Rasoulof includes clips of real protests, as well as the gut-wrenching no-win situation Najmeh finds herself in. It’s a terrific performance by Soheila Golestani in a terrific movie from Mohammad Rasoulof.

WATCH THE TRAILER

Leave a Comment » | Drama, World Cinema/Foreign | Tagged: , , , , , | Permalink
Posted by David Ferguson

THE LAST SHOWGIRL (2024)

January 9, 2025

Greetings again from the darkness. I get that many would quickly toss this one aside without so much as a second thought. After all, Pamela Anderson hasn’t been featured much in the last decade (or two), and most only recall her from “Baywatch” in the 1990’s and, umm, perhaps an infamously intimate video. My advice would be to reconsider. She’s now 57 years old and is absolutely terrific in this film from director Gia Coppola (granddaughter of legendary director Francis Ford Coppola; her big screen debut was as baby Zoe in NEW YORK STORIES, 1989). The screenplay is from TV scribe Kate Gersten (“Mozart in the Jungle”).

The film opens with Shelly (Ms. Anderson) in a close-up during an audition. She’s obviously quite nervous and a bit out of her comfort zone. It turns out most of the movie is a flashback that leads up to the full audition, including her verbal sparring with the show’s casting director (Jason Schwartzman, director Gia Coppola’s cousin). We soon learn that Shelly is a veteran dancer who has been a part of the ‘Razzle Dazzle’ burlesque show in Las Vegas for 38 years. The show’s promotional posters from the late 1980’s feature a young Shelly – and she’s been there ever since.

We experience the frenetic energy and near chaos backstage during the show, as Shelly and her fellow dancers, Mary-Anne (Brenda Song, THE SOCIAL NETWORK, 2010) and Jodie (Kiernan Shipka, “Mad Men”) juggle for dressing room space and costume changes between numbers. The two younger dancers look up to Shelly, who even fills the role of mother-figure for Jodie – a youngster dealing with family issues. All of the timing is coordinated by the Stage Manager Eddie (Dave Bautista, GUARDIANS OF THE GALAXY, 2014), a figure of calm who has a history with Shelly.

Shelly’s best friend is Annette (Oscar winner Jamie Lee Curtis), who plays an aging cocktail waitress trying to hang on despite the generational shifts. What seems quite clear is that all of these folks are caught in a web of day-to-day survival – never able to get ahead (despite a career spanning almost 4 decades). When the new owners decide to shut down Razzle Dazzle in favor of a circus, Shelly experiences double panic mode. Not only is her livelihood at stake, but her estranged daughter Hannah (Billie Lourd, “American Horror Story” and daughter of Carrie Fisher) is showing signs of wanting to reconnect with, or at least make sense of, a mother who chose the stage over her. The two share some emotional scenes.

Many will be surprised at the range Pamela Anderson shows in her performance, and the story itself should not be overlooked. Razzle Dazzle acts as a stand-in for the life so many folks have led, and just how untethered and lost they feel when the rug is pulled from the only life they’ve known. Shelly mentions a couple of times how she’s always having to defend her life, somehow not recognizing the need … even when Hannah is standing face to face with her. There’s a lot here, and I’m hoping movie lovers give this one a shot.

Opens in theaters on January 10, 2025

WATCH THE TRAILER

Leave a Comment » | Drama | Tagged: , , , , , , , , , | Permalink
Posted by David Ferguson

BETTER MAN (2024)

January 9, 2025

Greetings again from the darkness. There may have been a movie that surprised me more than this one during 2024, but off the top of my head, I can’t think of one. My expectations were low for a film based on the true story of a British boy band pop star whose music I wasn’t too familiar with … oh, and he’s played by a human-sized CGI chimp. Robbie Williams is the pop star, and though he has little popularity or recognition in the United States, his story is quite interesting … and certainly presented in a creative and entertaining manner by writer-director Michael Gracey (THE GREATEST SHOWMAN, 2017) and co-writers Simon Gleeson and Oliver Cole.

Calling young Robbie Williams an outcast is not done for dramatic effect. His troubled youth and home life morphed into an opportunity to join Take That, a boy band who hit it big in the 1990’s.  Booze, drugs, and depression are too often part of the story for those who reach celebrity status, and that’s certainly the case with Williams … as is his infidelity while on tour, and his ‘Daddy issues’, thanks to a father (Steve Pemberton) who dumps the family to pursue his own flirtations with fame – yet never shying away from sprinkling in a bit of envy while lecturing his son. If you’ve always wanted to see Oasis insult and humiliate another pop star, your wish will come true, although we doubt neither Liam nor Noel are having to act much in the scene.

Robbie Williams himself answers the big question early on. This is how he sees himself: a performing monkey. And the monkey, though not real of course, does a terrific job of winning us over to the point where we no longer have that initial ‘what the heck’ look on our face. The reason this works is that director Gracey and subject Williams never back away from playing this approach as directly as it shows on screen. It may be a gimmick, but it’s not played for a final ‘gotcha’ moment.

The music is on full display here, and Williams’ performance at Knebworth is excellent, but the real showstopper is “Rock DJ”, which along with the montage, provides us with a bit of history lesson on Take That. It’s a world class film scene and one of the best of the year. The personal aspects may not play quite so well. The inner-band rivalry with Gary (Jake Simmonce), and the manner in which he treats his relationship with girlfriend and also famous Nicole Appleton (Raechelle Bano) make him out to be more of a beast (and less interesting) than the one performing on stage. Still, I don’t hesitate to proclaim this to be the best music biopic of the year featuring a CGI chimp in the lead role.

Opens in theaters on January 10, 2025

WATCH THE TRAILER

Leave a Comment » | Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, Musical | Tagged: , , , , , , , | Permalink
Posted by David Ferguson

SUPER/MAN: THE CHRISTOPHER REEVE STORY (2024, doc)

January 4, 2025

Greetings again from the darkness. Almost all little kids imagine themselves as Superman, a larger-than-life figure who accomplishes incredible things … while flying through the air! Filmmakers Ian Bonhote and Peter Ettedgui collaborate again, this time to tell the story of the man who became Superman on screen for a new generation, and then, after a horrible accident, became a real-life inspiration and advocate for so many folks around the world. We also note that it’s impossible to tell the Christopher Reeve story without also gaining insight into his equally determined wife and caregiver, Dana Reeve.

“You are still you, and I love you.” These are the words Dana spoke to Christopher after the 1995 riding accident when his horse refused to jump a fence, sending Reeve flying in such a way that the landing left him a quadriplegic near death. Rather than fading, her words gained strength over time, right up until his death in 2004. The film offers a profile of Reeve’s early days, first as a roommate of Robin Williams at Julliard, and later as an up-and-coming actor. There is discussion of his attempts to break away from the Superman cape, most noteworthy in films like SOMEWHERE IN TIME (1980) and DEATHTRAP (1982).

Personal insight is provided by Reeve’s own children, Gae Exton (his ex and mother of two of his kids), and friends and colleagues – Whoopi Goldberg, Jeff Daniels, and Glenn Close. Some of this is focused on his post-injury career when he pursued acting and directing (1998 TV Movie, REAR WINDOW), yet the most personal and insightful bits come courtesy of the home movies through the years, offering a window into the man, rather than the actor. It’s that man that shines through once he transitions into Christopher Reeve, activist for spinal injuries.

Reeve displayed little self-pity, instead determined to move forward with a new life where his celebrity status could bring attention (and money) to the cause. He gave speeches (the Democratic Convention) and made appearances (one at the Academy Awards ceremony less than a year after his accident). Always by his side was Dana. She was an incredible caregiver, yet so much more as she shared his determination in fundraising and medical research. A little off topic, but there’s a clip of her singing in 1987, displaying significant talent.

A devastatingly emotional sequence occurs as we see the family visiting Reeve’s death bed. He was 52 years old when he passed. Proving that the universe bears no sense of fairness, non-smoker Dana was diagnosed with lung cancer less than a year later, and died at age 44, a mere 17 months after Christopher’s death. It’s rare for a documentary to deliver such personal insight, and even rarer for one to pack such an emotional wallop. The stories of Christopher and Dana Reeve serve to remind us of what matters in life … that’s their legacy (more so than a cape).

*On a personal note, I sat by Christopher Reeve at the LA Coliseum during an NFL playoff game between the Cowboys and Rams in January 1979. He took pleasure in talking trash to the young man (me) wearing the Cowboys jersey … at least until the good guys took a commanding lead and he left early.

WATCH THE TRAILER

Leave a Comment » | Documentary | Tagged: , , , , | Permalink
Posted by David Ferguson

SEPTEMBER 5 (2024)

January 3, 2025

Greetings again from the darkness. The 1972 Olympics are remembered for a few highlights. Swimmer Mark Spitz set seven world records on his way to seven gold medals. Belarusian gymnast Olga Korbut won three gold medals (although not in the all-around). The United States and Russia played one of the strangest and most controversial games in Olympics history. And most importantly, the 1972 Munich Olympics are remembered for the tragedy surrounding 10 members of Israel’s team being taken hostage by a masked Palestinian militant group.

Writer-director Tim Fehlbaum and co-writers Moritz Binder and Alex David recreate the events from the perspective of the ABC television production crew. For some historical perspective, this was the first OIympics with widespread and comprehensive live television coverage. It was also the first Olympics held in Germany since 1936 (the Jesse Owens’ games). These games were merely 27 years after the end of WWII. Quick math tells us that 27 years ago from this film’s release was 1997, the year Princess Diana died. To put it plainly, physical and emotional wounds had not completely healed, and Germany was striving to put the past out of mind.

Renowned ABC sports producer Roone Arledge (played here by Peter Sarsgaard) is the man running the Olympics coverage. Newbie broadcast producer Geoffrey Mason (John Magaro, PAST LIVES, 2023) is brought in to run the “off hours”, while Arledge rests. Mason’s experience includes covering minor league baseball, so this is his first shot at the big time. His supervisor, Marvin Bader (played by Ben Chaplin, THE THIN RED LINE, 1998) has confidence in his young protégé, but things go sideways quickly when gunfire is heard.

The genius of the film stems from Director Fehlbaum and Cinematographer Marcus Forderer (I ORIGINS, 2014) choosing to shoot everything inside the ABC control room. This heightens the claustrophobia and pressure as the crew struggles with how best to handle this developing and obviously historic moment. It’s no longer about swimming and sprinting, but now it’s ABC Sports versus ABC News … and since possession is the proverbial 9/10 of the law, Arledge fights to keep the story with his team who is in close proximity. Anchor Jim McKay is seen in archival footage, while reporter Peter Jennings is on the grounds. Translator Marianne Gebhardt (Leonie Benesch, who was amazing in THE TEACHER’S LOUNGE, 2023) is the only one who speaks German and she is vital in her reporting of what’s being broadcast via local radio.

It’s difficult to convey just how much tension runs through this film for both the television crew and the viewers. Ten members of Israel’s Olympic team was taken hostage inside the Olympic Village by the masked Palestinian militant group Black September. We know how history played out over those hours and it’s chilling to revisit from this perspective. The geopolitical aspects are touched upon (Bader was Jewish), but this isn’t about that. Journalism may be heavily criticized these days, but it’s historic moments like this when we depend on competent trained professionals to tell (and show the stories the world needs to know. The haunting archival clips used here add to the quasi-documentary feel.

Opening in select theaters on December 13, 2024 and wide on January 10, 2025

WATCH THE TRAILER

2 Comments | Drama, Thriller | Tagged: , , , , , , , , | Permalink
Posted by David Ferguson

THE WILD ROBOT (2024, animation)

January 2, 2025

Greetings again from the darkness. With four outstanding animated films released in 2024, this one adapted from Peter Brown’s 2016 book by director Chris Sanders (HOW TO TRAIN YOUR DRAGON, 2010) stands above the others thanks to a tremendous story and fascinating characters. This is one for all ages and all types of movie lovers. It’s simply that good.

A new-age robot washes ashore. With no assigned customer and no programmed task, “Roz” is a bit confused on how best to proceed. This leads to a trip into the forest where she shifts to ‘learning’ mode, and soon enough is speaking to the various wild animals – finding ways to ‘help’ most of them. It’s a terrific opening few sequences drawing us in with awe and surprisingly … character connection. A tragic accident finds an undersized and orphaned gosling basically playing “Are You My Mother?” with Roz. The 1960 book by that name is a kids’ classic written by PD Eastman and edited by Dr. Seuss, and re-read countless times by most parents.

What follows is an incredible adventure featuring many different creatures, each with distinct personalities. Only these aren’t the cartoon characters we are accustomed to seeing in animation. None here are training for a solo on stage or strategizing to escape the zoo. These are wild animals in nature, and sometimes bad things happen … and sometimes good things happen. As bonds are formed and trust gained, it’s wonderful to see the community come together. Much/most of the story revolves around three outcasts: Roz the robot who is searching for her task, Brightbill the gosling who is ignored by the skein of geese migrating, and Fink the fox whose loneliness matches his sly manipulations.

A talented and deep voice cast includes Lupita Nyong’O (Roz), Pedro Pascal (Fink the fox), Kit Connor (undersized and orphaned Brightbill), Bill Nighy (Longneck, leader of the geese), Stephanie Hsu (Vontra, leader of the retrieval bots), scene-stealing Matt Berry (Paddler the beaver), Ving Rhames (Thunderbolt, hawk), Mark Hamill (Thorn the grizzly bear), Catherine O’Hara (Pinktail the possom). It’s a lineup of celebrities, but this is no ego exhibition. The characters are developed and story is multi-faceted. Some scenes are tense, while others are capped with humorous moments (“male bovine excrement” cracked me up). There is an overall guiding message of kindness, cooperation, and putting others ahead of self.

The film’s score is by Oscar winner Kris Bowers, and Dreamworks, in their ongoing rivalry with Pixar, has delivered depth and artistry instead of the usual cash grab on project for kids. Without a specific task to complete, Roz manages to be a guiding light for Brightbill and a partner to Fink, all while being an asset to the community … even though she looks a bit worse for wear by the end. For those who typically shy away from animation, this one is worthy of a watch. This is expert filmmaking.

WATCH THE TRAILER

Leave a Comment » | Animation | Tagged: , , , , , , , , , , , | Permalink
Posted by David Ferguson

SING SING (2024)

December 31, 2024

Greetings again from the darkness. Since I missed this one on its initial run earlier this year, it became part of my end of year movie marathon where I catch up on the films that slipped through during the previous few months. Even though the premise doesn’t much sound like one I’d embrace, I’m so glad I worked this one into the schedule. On the surface, following a group of prisoners as they work to put on a stage presentation hardly sounds like a desirable form of entertainment, but what a pleasant surprise this one turned out to be.

Buckle up for a second as I try to explain the foundation of this one. John H Richardson had his article “The Sing Sing Follies” published in Esquire magazine. The article was based on Brent Buell’s play “Breakin’ the Mummy Code” which was a prison stage production. The story was enhanced by former prisoners Clarence Divine Eye Maclin and John Divine G Whitfield, and the screenplay was co-written by Cline Bentley and the film’s director Greg Kwedar. Furthermore, Divine Eye and Divine G are both characters in the film, with Clarence Maclin portraying himself. What a wonderfully tangled web of production this is.

The amazingly talented Colman Domingo (MA RAINEY’S BLACK BOTTOM, 2020) plays Divine G, the unofficial ringleader of the local RTA (Rehabilitation Through Arts). While he works as a recruiter and writer for the troupe, it’s Brent Buell (played by Paul Raci, SOUND OF METAL, 2019), who directs and co-writes the productions. The dynamics change quickly when new guy, Divine Eye (Maclin), shows up to audition for the lead role that typically goes to Divine G. The two men couldn’t be much different as Divine G is an energetic and artsy guy who smiles a lot, while Divine Eye is an intimidating hulk of a man whose stone-faced expression only changes when he sneers.

It’s quite interesting to see the new play come together after suggestions from the cast include such aspects as time travel, Hamlet, Gladiators, Robin Hood, and Freddie Kreuger. About the time we get comfortable watching this group of men bond for the purposes of the show, reality strikes back in the form of parole hearings. Despite the distraction, these men never forget they are incarcerated and have little daily freedom. It’s especially tough and unfair and heart-breaking when one has been imprisoned for a crime they didn’t commit.

Much of the cast is made up of men who were previously imprisoned, including Clarence Maclin, who along with Colman Domingo (especially expressive in close-ups) delivers a powerhouse performance. The score by Bryce Dessner (THE TWO POPES, 2019) is terrific, and director Kwedar includes vintage clips at the end of the actual prison shows. Despite the feel-good nature of the prison shows, there is an underlying message that happy endings are not guaranteed. Let’s just hope no parents mistake this for the 2016 PG-rated animated film, SING.

WATCH THE TRAILER

Leave a Comment » | Drama | Tagged: , , , , , , , , , | Permalink
Posted by David Ferguson

ALL WE IMAGINE AS LIGHT (2024, India)

December 29, 2024

Greetings again from the darkness. With a population of more than 20 million people, Mumbai is one of the most densely populated places on the planet. It would seem impossible to feel alone or isolated in such a place. In this follow-up to her feature film debut, A NIGHT OF KNOWING NOTHING (2021), Indian filmmaker Payal Kapadia begins with a documentary style overview of the city with multi-dialect voiceovers recapping personal experiences with life in the city. “In Mumbai, there is work and money.”

Writer-director Kapadia then proceeds to highlight the very different challenges of three women who work at a busy local hospital. Pradha (a superb Kani Kasrudi) is a senior nurse. Her younger roommate Anu (Divya Pradha) has an administrative position, while Pradha’s best friend Parvaty (Chhya Kadam) is a cook in the cafeteria. Each has their own story. Pradha’s husband took off for Germany not long after their arranged marriage, and they have had little contact in over a year. Anu has a bit of a rebellious streak and has fallen for a Muslim boy named Shiaz (Hridhu Haroon), a cross-religion taboo. In the path of development, the widow Parvaty is being threatened with eviction from her apartment of 22 years, as her husband failed to leave the necessary ownership papers.

Pradha is not a cold woman, yet she’s certainly not prone to expressing emotions in front of others. So, when she cuddles on the floor with the fancy rice maker she assumes was sent by her husband, we understand this is a dramatic moment for her. Pradha tries to counsel Anu on the danger of spoiling her reputation, but Anu is strong enough to pursue her own desires – despite “helpful” date recommendations from her own mother. The generational differences are stark. Dr. Manoj (Azees Nedumangad) has a quiet crush on Pradha and offers his personally crafted poem to her as proof. When Parvaty decides to return to the seaside village of her childhood, Anu and Pradha assist with the move.

The intricacies of the delicate relationships among the three women is most evident and impactful during this final segment. The sadness and resignation inferred by “You can’t escape your fate” is contested in this third act. Pradha’s reserved nature and gentleness mask her inner-strength, and a terrific sequence occurs where she performs CPR on a man on the beach, and what follows is a touching, surreal vision.

The contrast between the hustle and constant movement of big city Mumbai (even in the time before sunrise) and the beach village is noteworthy as the three women are actually able to enjoy a moment. In fact, finding joy in a life lacking in joy is a key lesson here … in other words, making the best of one’s situation. A sometimes playful piano score from Dhritiman Das Topshe helps with the tone set by cinematographer Ranabir Das and the heavy dose of blue tint. The film financing was dependent on multi-country (mostly European) participation, and having the film overlooked as India’s submission for this year’s Oscar consideration was a clear slight to the talented Payal Kapadia. It’s such a shame, as this is without a doubt one of the best films of the year.

WATCH THE TRAILER

Leave a Comment » | Drama, World Cinema/Foreign | Tagged: , , , , , , , , | Permalink
Posted by David Ferguson

« Previous Entries
Next Entries »