Greetings again from the darkness. With a population of more than 20 million people, Mumbai is one of the most densely populated places on the planet. It would seem impossible to feel alone or isolated in such a place. In this follow-up to her feature film debut, A NIGHT OF KNOWING NOTHING (2021), Indian filmmaker Payal Kapadia begins with a documentary style overview of the city with multi-dialect voiceovers recapping personal experiences with life in the city. “In Mumbai, there is work and money.”
Writer-director Kapadia then proceeds to highlight the very different challenges of three women who work at a busy local hospital. Pradha (a superb Kani Kasrudi) is a senior nurse. Her younger roommate Anu (Divya Pradha) has an administrative position, while Pradha’s best friend Parvaty (Chhya Kadam) is a cook in the cafeteria. Each has their own story. Pradha’s husband took off for Germany not long after their arranged marriage, and they have had little contact in over a year. Anu has a bit of a rebellious streak and has fallen for a Muslim boy named Shiaz (Hridhu Haroon), a cross-religion taboo. In the path of development, the widow Parvaty is being threatened with eviction from her apartment of 22 years, as her husband failed to leave the necessary ownership papers.
Pradha is not a cold woman, yet she’s certainly not prone to expressing emotions in front of others. So, when she cuddles on the floor with the fancy rice maker she assumes was sent by her husband, we understand this is a dramatic moment for her. Pradha tries to counsel Anu on the danger of spoiling her reputation, but Anu is strong enough to pursue her own desires – despite “helpful” date recommendations from her own mother. The generational differences are stark. Dr. Manoj (Azees Nedumangad) has a quiet crush on Pradha and offers his personally crafted poem to her as proof. When Parvaty decides to return to the seaside village of her childhood, Anu and Pradha assist with the move.
The intricacies of the delicate relationships among the three women is most evident and impactful during this final segment. The sadness and resignation inferred by “You can’t escape your fate” is contested in this third act. Pradha’s reserved nature and gentleness mask her inner-strength, and a terrific sequence occurs where she performs CPR on a man on the beach, and what follows is a touching, surreal vision.
The contrast between the hustle and constant movement of big city Mumbai (even in the time before sunrise) and the beach village is noteworthy as the three women are actually able to enjoy a moment. In fact, finding joy in a life lacking in joy is a key lesson here … in other words, making the best of one’s situation. A sometimes playful piano score from Dhritiman Das Topshe helps with the tone set by cinematographer Ranabir Das and the heavy dose of blue tint. The film financing was dependent on multi-country (mostly European) participation, and having the film overlooked as India’s submission for this year’s Oscar consideration was a clear slight to the talented Payal Kapadia. It’s such a shame, as this is without a doubt one of the best films of the year.
Posted by David Ferguson
Greetings again from the darkness. Oscar winner Nicole Kidman long ago entrenched herself as one of the best and most daring actors working today. Not one to shy away from risky material, she’s appeared in such films as EYES WIDE SHUT (1999), DOGVILLE (2003), BIRTH (2004), and THE NORTHMAN (2022) to name just a few. It’s her talent and willingness to put herself out there that has earned such respect among peers and fans. However, despite that admiration, this latest is one of my least favorite films of the year, and one that I found almost no positives to discuss. I will readily admit this opinion puts me in the extreme minority.
Greetings again from the darkness. I’ve said it many times, and it still holds true, Oscar winner Pedro Almodovar is the most accomplished male filmmaker when it comes to creating interesting female characters and spinning female-centric stories. Almodovar’s first English-language feature-length film is one he’s adapted from the 2020 novel, “What Are You Going Through”, by Sigrid Nunez. It features two Oscar winners, Julianne Moore and Tilda Swinton, both extraordinarily talented.
Greetings again from the darkness. Too many view WWII as just another page in history books, when in fact, so much changed around the globe because of that war. Almost 80 years later, the war continues to provide stories for filmmakers, and when it comes to storytelling, few do it better than this latest from writer-director (actor-turned-filmmaker) Brady Corbet and his co-writer (and romantic partner) Mona Fastvold. The two had previously collaborated on THE CHILDHOOD OF A LEADER (2015) and VOX LUX (2018).
Greetings again from the darkness. Some filmmakers have earned the benefit of the doubt to the point where each film they release is worthy of consideration. Luca Guadagnino is one such filmmaker. He first captured my attention with I AM LOVE (2009) and has since followed that with such interesting films as A BIGGER SPLASH (2015), CALL ME BY YOUR NAME (2017), SUSPIRIA (2018), BONES AND ALL (2022), and CHALLENGERS, his first film released in 2024. This time he and his CHALLENGERS screenwriter, Justin Kuritzkes, take on the 1985 William S Burroughs novella, “Queer”, which was linked to his 1953 novel, “Junkie”. Taking on the writing of William S Burroughs is challenging enough as a reader, much less as a filmmaker.
Greetings again from the darkness. Every movie review provides the opportunity to walk the line between telling enough, but not too much. Some movies pose more of a challenge than others, and this is one. Director Steffan Haars (the ‘New Kids’ movies) and writer-actor Nick Frost team up to deliver a devilish and campy folk horror-slasher-comedy that brings a bit of innovation to genre that could use a boost.
Greetings again from the darkness. Playwright August Wilson has a nice string of his stage work being adapted for the big screen. First, there was FENCES (2018), then MA RANEY’S BLACK BOTTOM (2022), and now this latest is the first feature film from writer-director Malcolm Washington (son of Denzel), with a screenplay co-written with Virgil Williams (MUDBOUND, 2017). This thoughtful allegory asks the question, when is a piano more than just a piano?
Greetings again from the darkness. Like many of you, I’m not usually a fan of sequels. Too often they feel like a money grab or an unapologetically opportunistic way to capitalize on previous success without much creativity or artistry required. Of course, there are exceptions. Sometimes sequels advance the story or offer additional development on an interesting character. So where does this one fit? It’s been almost a quarter-century since GLADIATOR (2000) received 12 Oscar nominations, winning 5, including Best Picture. The original is a film I revere. Director Ridley Scott is back at the helm, and at age 86, he proves he’s still a master of scope and scale and visceral action sequences.
Greetings again from the darkness. Who is the good witch and who is the bad one? For those of us whose obsession with the classic 1939 film version of L Frank Baum’s 1900 novel has lasted from childhood through adulthood, it has always been crystal clear that the Wicked Witch of the West was bad and Glinda the Good Witch was so-named for obvious reasons. Then along came Gregory Maguire’s 1995 novel “Wicked: The Life and Times of the Wicked Witch of the West”, and the subsequent 20+ year Broadway run of the stage musical, which generated many new fans. And now we have a film adaptation of the stage production is directed by the talented Jon M Chu (CRAZY RICH ASIANS, 2018) with a screenplay co-written by Dana Fox (CRUELLA, 2021) and Winnie Holzman (who wrote the musical book for the stage musical). Could it be that the line between good and evil is not so clear? Or even that others have manipulated the situation to ensure a villain exists? I’m so excited for Oz fans to watch this.
Greetings again from the darkness. It’s that time of year when we get bombarded with Christmas movies. Some are light-hearted comedies, while others play off the elevated emotions of the holiday season. Most of these seem to be harmless, although some are so lame that we can barely watch. Yet it seems most every year one or two surprise us by packing a punch. Writer-director Tyler Taormina and co-writer Eric Berger re-team after their underappreciated HAM ON RYE (2019) for the most unique Christmas movie we will likely watch this year.