Greetings again from the darkness. This is at least the eighth film adaptation of a story by Cesc Gay: THE PEOPLE UPSTAIRS (Spain, 2020), VICINI DI CASA (Italy, 2022), THE NEIGHBORS FROM UPSTAIRS (Switzerland, 2023), V DOBREM I ZLEM (Czech Republic, 2024), NEPRILICHNYE GOSTI (Russia, 2024), MAYBE MORE (France, 2024), THE PEOPLE UPSTAIRS (S Korea, 2025). Clearly, it’s a story and situation that resonates with many couples, regardless of geography, language, or culture … and director Olivia Wilde provides an American spin with assistance from co-writers Will McCormack (Oscar winner, TOY STORY 4) and Rashida Jones (“Parks and Recreation”).
In addition to directing the film, Ms. Wilde also stars as Angela, who is married to Joe, played by Seth Rogen. We see a bored Joe barely paying attention to the school band his job requires him to conduct, and he then trudges home on a folding bicycle that he wrestles through every possible obstacle. When he arrives home, Angela is putting the finishing touches on dinner party details … and the two immediately begin bickering over everything either of them says or does. Angela is high-strung and intent on making a good impression with the upstairs neighbors she has invited, while Joe makes no promises about avoiding the topic of wall-shaking sexcapades those same neighbors engage in, regularly disrupting his serene evenings of pot smoking.
The stage is set for an evening of conflict, and although it begins amicably enough, things do spiral into an emotional hurricane that creates more noise and emotion than any of those intrusive sounds Joe despises. Oscar winner Penelope Cruz is Pina, and Edward Norton plays her boyfriend Hawk. These are coy and cool personas who are sizing up Angela and Joe, for reasons most will identify almost immediately.
The first half (or more) of the film seems designed as a set up for a stream of Seth Rogen one-liners, and judging from audience reactions at the screening, these quips will strike a chord with his fans. However, there is a lot more going on here than merely a platform for punchlines. Relationships are often complicated by a lack of communication, and that’s on full display here. Sex is a huge part of their marital problems and an even bigger part of the evening’s conversation, yet sex is more of a conduit to underlying issues that may be exposed before this party ends.
The four characters are consistently unlikable, and yet, this works thanks to the proficiency of the actors, the message delivered by the story, and the expert direction by Olivia Wilde. She previously directed DON’T WORRY DARLING (2022) and BOOKSMART (2017), the latter of which was excellent. This story and setting seem to be a better fit for the stage than the screen, yet Ms. Wilde ensures the pacing and movements within the apartment are precise and keep us engaged. There is a certain audience that will be drawn to the Seth Rogen comedy, while some will be caught off guard by the relationship tension. For some viewers, there is a certain pleasure to be found in comparing the film to the Mike Nichols classic, WHO’S AFRAID OF VIRGINIA WOOLF? (1966). As uncomfortable as it is to watch, some will find solace and relief that their own relationship hasn’t fallen this far (hopefully).
SELECT THEATERS JUNE 26, EVERYWHERE JULY 10
Posted by David Ferguson 
Movie Reviews from the Dark 