Greetings again from the darkness. Playwright August Wilson has a nice string of his stage work being adapted for the big screen. First, there was FENCES (2018), then MA RANEY’S BLACK BOTTOM (2022), and now this latest is the first feature film from writer-director Malcolm Washington (son of Denzel), with a screenplay co-written with Virgil Williams (MUDBOUND, 2017). This thoughtful allegory asks the question, when is a piano more than just a piano?
The film opens on Independence Day in 1911, and as fireworks fill the sky, a group of men steal a piano from their slave owner. We quickly jump ahead 25 years to 1936 and find Boy Willie (John David Washington, also son of Denzel) and his friend Lymon (Ray Fisher, “True Detective”) taking a wagon full of watermelons to Boy Willie’s sister house. The plan is to sell the watermelons and his sister’s piano so that Boy Willie can purchase a plot of land where his ancestors worked as slaves. It’s a simple plan that makes sense … except his sister, Berniece (Danielle Deadwyler, so good in TILL, 2022) has no intention of selling the piano, a family heirloom.
Berniece and her daughter Maretha (Skylar Aleece Smith) live in Uncle Doaker’s (a reserved Samuel L Jackson) home and the piano sits, unplayed, in the living room. Ironically, it’s Boy Willie who talks us – and Maretha – through the piano’s history, including how his grandfather had hand-carved family faces into the front. Maretha was previously clueless as her mother Berniece had chosen to carry the weight of history to herself. The more brother and sister argue, the more activity from the spirits occur – known as ‘Ghost of the Yellow Dog.”
Doaker attempts to keep the peace, while wannabe preacher Avery (Corey Hawkins, THE COLOR PURPLE, 2023) relentlessly woos Berniece. Danielle Deadwyler delivers a remarkable performance as she remains steadfast. With a polar opposite personality to brother Boy Willie, she is a picture of pride and strength, and delivers the film’s best line directed to her brother, “All you ever had going for you in life is talk.” For those who don’t appreciate the stage-to-screen adaptations, the recommendation is to focus on the storytelling, rather than the sometimes distracting staginess. It’s a terrific script and, led by Ms. Deadwyler, the acting is mostly top notch.
Available on Netflix
Posted by David Ferguson
Greetings again from the darkness. Sometimes no matter how hard we try to like a movie, it simply doesn’t work for us. In those instances, I typically attempt to focus on what I did like and offer an explanation of why it fell short of expectations. And it’s that word, “expectations”, that is usually the culprit. High expectations often lead to disappointment, whereas ‘low’ or ‘no’ expectations at least have a shot of ending up a pleasant surprise. So when the writer-director of SILVER LININGS PLAYBOOK (2012) and THE FIGHTER (2010) rolls out his first film in seven years, and his cast is filled with Oscar winners, Oscar nominees, and other talented actors … well, high expectations are in order. Unfortunately, so is the disappointment.
