Greetings again from the darkness. I’ve said it many times, and it still holds true, Oscar winner Pedro Almodovar is the most accomplished male filmmaker when it comes to creating interesting female characters and spinning female-centric stories. Almodovar’s first English-language feature-length film is one he’s adapted from the 2020 novel, “What Are You Going Through”, by Sigrid Nunez. It features two Oscar winners, Julianne Moore and Tilda Swinton, both extraordinarily talented.
Noted author Ingrid (Julianne Moore) is at a book signing for her latest work on the fear of death. Jumping the line and surprising her is her long ago friend Martha (Tilda Swinton). The two previously worked together, are genuinely happy to embrace, and meet up after the signing. Martha informs Ingrid that she has stage 3 cervical cancer and is beginning an experimental treatment. While visiting Martha at the hospital, Ingrid not only learns the treatment has failed, but soon after is hit with what can be termed, “a huge ask”. Having no interest in continuing treatment, Martha informs Ingrid that she wants a friendly face ‘in the room next door’ when she takes the magic “goodbye” pill.
What follows is not a moral debate about fighting to live or taking one’s own life. Ingrid has made her decision. The lingering question is, how much can be expected in a friendship? Ingrid admits Martha was not her first choice – the others turned her down. Once Martha reluctantly agrees, Ingrid rents a stunning home in the woods … very private and very serene. As you might expect, Almodovar highlights many shots throughout with his trademark use of color, geometric lines, and architectural design. The women, the house, the setting, the art, the clothes, and the sets are all gorgeous. Special recognition goes to Cinematographer Eduard Grau (the equally gorgeous A SINGLE MAN, 2009), Production Desiger Inbal Weinberg (THE LOST DAUGHTER, 2021), and Costume Designer Bina Daigeler (VOLVER, 2006).
With the two women sharing the house, Ingrid anxiously keeps an eye on whether the bedroom door is closed or open (the ‘sign’), while Martha has flashbacks to her time as a war journalist on the front lines. Ingrid meets up with Damian (John Turturro), her former lover and something else the two women shared. Damian is a doom and gloom type focused on climate change and global crisis. This stands in stark contrast to Ingrid’s optimism. Of course, Martha has planned everything so that Ingrid is not in danger of being charged with assisting euthanasia, although a religious fanatic police officer (Alessandro Nivola) questions her aggressively.
There are some lovely moments shared between friends, and yet there are also scenes that could have used a sharper edge to the dialogue – especially the exhaustive exposition early on as Martha runs down the timeline of her entire life (much that Ingrid would have already known). There are references to Buster Keaton and John Huston’s movie, “The Dead”, and Almodovar throws in a nice touch when Martha’s daughter makes an appearance towards the end. Martha’s need/desire for connection, familiarity, and companionship are all believable, yet that “favor” remains a whopper.
Opens in NYC AND LA theaters on December 20, 2024, expanding in January
Posted by David Ferguson 
Greetings again from the darkness. “We’re all passing for something or other.” Irene (played by Tessa Thompson) speaks the line that cuts to the quick of Nella Larsen’s 1929 novel, adapted here by first time writer-director Rebecca Hall. We are familiar with Ms. Hall’s many film projects as an actor, and her debut as a director shows immense promise. Ms. Larsen’s novel was inspired by her own life as a mixed-race woman.
Movie Reviews from the Dark 