Greetings again from the darkness. We can pick our friends, but not our family or neighbors. However, we can (and do) speculate on and judge our neighbors – and that’s what occurs in this smart little film from writer-director Leon Prudovsky and co-writer Dmitri Malinsky. The premise of the film may initially seem absurd to some, but the final version is touching and quite entertaining.
A short prologue takes us to 1934 in Eastern Europe where a large Jewish family is enjoying their time together and posing for a family portrait. We then flash forward to 1960 South America. It’s after the war, and Polsky (screen vet David Hayman) is living a life of solitude in a dilapidated countryside home. Polsky still grieves for his many losses, while wearing the mark of a Holocaust survivor. He’s a grumpy man who shares pleasantries with neither the friendly postal carrier nor the inquisitive lady inquiring about the empty house next door … a house he would much prefer remain vacant. Polsky spends his days tending the black rose bush, which is his bond to happier times, especially those with his wife.
The previously mentioned inquisitive lady turns out to be Frau Kaltenbrunner (Olivia Sibush), charged with finding a home for the mysterious Mr. Herzog (Udo Kier), a process that means Polsky now has a neighbor – one whose German Shepard named Wolfie breaks through the fence and damages the beloved rose bush. The two men barely acknowledge each other, except for a property line negotiation. Polsky catches a glimpse of Herzog’s eyes without the sunglasses and immediately pegs him as Hitler. Heavy duty research follows as Polsky displays an urgency missing from his life for many years.
Remarkably, the premise is bizarre, yet rather than be the main thrust, it merely leads to the crux of the story. Of course, we understand why Polsky might not believe the media reports of Hitler’s bunker suicide, but he’s taken aback by how investigators show little interest in his evidence, and are more concerned about his own mental health. Almost accidentally, the two men slowly begin relaxing their defenses towards the other. A chess board thaws the ice, as does the slow-to-come conversation. What we soon see are two men, burdened by the past, finally opening themselves up to living again.
An odd twist is handled beautifully by the actors. A few bits of note to go with this one. Frau Kaltenbrunner’s last name is (probably not) coincidentally the same as that of Ernst Kaltenbrunner, former Director of Reich Security, and a convicted Nazi criminal. Our two lead actors, David Hayman and Udo Kier have had excellent careers dating back to the mid-60’s. Kier has long been a personal favorite, and he recently passed in November 2025. He also has a role in THE SECRET AGENT, Brazil’s submission for Best International Feature of 2025. The performances of these two men elevate the material and create emotion where it’s needed … and neither actor ever stoops to scene stealing. Prudovsky’s film is not just a pleasant surprise, it’s an excellent film worthy of attention.
Opens in theaters on January 9, 2026
Movie Reviews from the Dark 