Greetings again from the darkness. In the Mother Goose nursery rhyme, Jack and Jill not only went up the hill together, they also tumbled down. This latest from writer-director Samuel Van Grinsven and co-writer Jory Anast spin a Jack and Jill yarn that’s not nearly as cutesy, yet does involve some emotional tumbling … and one creepy spirit.
Horror film aficionados are accustomed to possession-themed stories, where someone from beyond takes over the body of one still living. The twist here … and it’s a good one … is that the spirit of Elizabeth actually (and regularly) switches between not one, but two characters who are both important to her. Elizabeth was a renowned artist who opted for a way out, leaving behind her two great loves – her wife Jill (Vicky Krieps, PHANTOM THREAD, 2017) and their stunning mountain lake home (the Southern Alps of New Zealand).
On the day of the funeral, Jack (Dacre Montgomery, very good in the upcoming WHAT WE HIDE, 2025) shows up, claiming Jill invited him by phone. It’s clear Jill has no idea who he is, or that Jack is Elizabeth’s only child – one given up many years ago for reasons that aren’t clear until much later. Elizabeth’s sister, Helen (a terrific Sarah Peirse) has kept the family secret all this time. Jill invites Jack to stay at the house, despite Helen making it obvious his presence is not appreciated.
Speaking of presence … we never see Elizabeth, but we know she’s there (and there). Jill sleeps next to the coffin, and every time she and Jack fall asleep, Elizabeth’s spirit does her thing. Mood and atmosphere are key here, and everyone (including Jack, Jill, and us viewers) is confused as to what the spirit of Elizabeth is trying to accomplish. Does the spirit want Jack and Jill to have the relationship that mom and son never did? Or is the spirit focused on having her beloved wife, and possibly the long lost son as well, join her in her new locale? The goal isn’t always clear, but it is always a bit creepy … which is good for the movie.
Cinematographer Tyson Perkins likely had a blast working with the combination of skilled actors, a stunning modern house, and the geographic terrain which could be both beautiful and treacherous – although the number of ‘eyeball shots’ were a bit eerie. A not so minor complaint is in regard to the low-level dialogue, which was exceptionally difficult to hear at times. Still, the acting here is superb, as is the piano-based score from composer Hanan Townshend (TO THE WONDER, 2012), and kudos to a horror movie that’s neither slasher, sequel, nor re-tread.
Opening in theaters on August 15, 2025
Movie Reviews from the Dark 