Greetings again from the darkness. It appears as though I’m one of the few early viewers who walked away without having been beguiled or enraptured with this musical prequel to Roald Dahl’s 1964 story, “Charlie and the Chocolate Factory”. Full disclosure requires me to admit that I actually found it a bit dull, and that’s mostly due to the lead performance by Timothy Chalamet. I understand that he’s the hottest young actor working today, and brings along an entire fan base, but for me, Willy Wonka should have a twinkle in his eye, a spring in his step, and enough charm to draw folks in … even at a younger age.
Writer-director Paul King and co-writer Simon Farnaby collaborated on the thoroughly entertaining PADDINGTON 2 (2017) and are back at it in this third film from Dahl’s classic children story. Most recently, there was Johnny Depp in Tim Burton’s CHARLIE AND THE CHOCOLATE FACTORY (2005), and it’s been more than 50 years since Gene Wilder bounded between charming and menacing in Mel Stuart’s WILLY WONKA & THE CHOCOLATE FACTORY (1971). King and Farnaby deliver a musical origin story which allows for a much nicer (or should it be sweeter) Willy Wonka, and instead sprinkles the menace on a few supporting characters, ensuring some dark themes are present.
A ”deal” with Willy’s mother (Sally Hawkins) has the illiterate Wonka arriving in town with only a few coins in his pocket, and a dream to build his chocolate factory. His innocence and naivety soon leave him penniless and contracted into indentured servitude, along with some others, at a shady laundry establishment run by the dentally challenged Mrs Scrubbitt (Oscar winner Olivia Colman) and her baritone behemoth assistant Bleacher (Tom Davis). Willy bonds with the others being held captive, including young orphan Noodle (Calah Lane), who somehow holds the same optimistic outlook as her new friend. Willy soon discovers that he has landed in the town with a chocolate cartel led by Slugworth (Paterson Joseph), Prodnose (Matt Lucas), and Fickelgruber (Mathew Baynton), the local chocolatiers who bribe the Police Chief (Keegan-Michael Key) with none other than … chocolate, in order to keep the new kid from selling his superior goodies.
Willy has even more challenges to deal with, including a knee-high, orange-faced Oompa-Loompa (Hugh Grant), who seeks restitution by stealing from Willy Wonka while he sleeps. Grant’s Oompa-Loompa is a definite highlight here (just as he was in PADDINGTON 2), especially during his song. The other familiar song in the film is “Pure Imagination”, though none of the new songs by Neil Hannon are particular catchy or memorable.
In addition to Grant’s sarcastic Oompa-Loompa, another highlight is certainly Nathan Crowley’s Production Design, ranging from Scrubbitt’s grungy basement to the picturesque town square and ultimately, the chocolate store sequence. The decision to have the young, idealistic Willy overflowing with optimism and lacking the grumpiness and menace of the grown Wonka makes sense for an origin story … I simply didn’t find it as magical, as entertaining, or as interesting.
Opens in theaters nationwide on December 15, 2023
Movie Reviews from the Dark 
Great review! I actually really enjoyed this movie. As a huge fan of the novel, it fulfilled my appetite. I could relate to the story of a chocolate maker because my mother is a baker. Here’s why I enjoyed it: